No Right to No Fault Trial; New York Appellate Court Rules

The Appellate Division has unanimously affirmed a trial court decision, which held that there is no right to litigate the allegation that a marriage has irretrievably broken down under New York’s no-fault divorce law.

Under New York’s no fault divorce law, DRL 170(7), a divorce will be granted where:

The relationship between husband and wife has broken down irretrievably for a period of at least six months, provided that one party has so stated under oath.

In an exhaustive review of the history of New York’s no fault divorce laws, the trial court concluded:

Under DRL § 170(7), the grounds cannot be disputed. Either a party swears the marriage is irretrievably broken or they do not. The grounds are established by the oath; there is no legislative requirement of a judicial finding on the reliability or veracity of the oath.

This decision is the latest, and the first by a New York appellate court, declaring that there is no right to a trial under New York’s no fault divorce law. According to the decision, the allegation in the complaint that the marriage has irretrievably broken down is sufficient to make out the case.  I would suspect that we have seen the last of grounds trials in divorces in New York.

 

 

9 Responses

  1. Thanks a ton for your post. I would like to write my opinion that the tariff of car insurance varies widely from one coverage to another, for the reason that there are so many different issues which give rise to the overall cost. For example, the brand name of the auto will have a huge bearing on the charge. A reliable older family car or truck will have a more economical premium when compared to a flashy expensive car.
  2. 11/4/2016 @ 12:33:17: lorem ipsum clementlaw.com
  3. 11/7/2016 clementlaw.com does it again! Quite a informative site and a good post. Thanks!
  4. 11/9/2016 @ 18:44:51 In my estimation, clementlaw.com does a excellent job of handling subjects of this kind! Even if sometimes intentionally contentious, the material posted is more often than not well-written and challenging.
  5. 11/11/2016 @ 10:54:58 Love clementlaw.com– very informative and a lot of stuff to see!
  6. clementlaw.com does it again! Very thoughtful site and a thought-provoking post. Nice work!
  7. I completely agree with your take on this topic and look forward to upcoming posts and comments here at clementlaw.com. Keep up the good work!
  8. clementlaw.com does it yet again! Quite a informative site and a thought-provoking article. Nice work!
  9. I'm gratified with the way that clementlaw.com deals with this type of topic. Generally on point, often controversial, always thoughtful and also stimulating.

Leave a comment

Contact Us Now!
(212) 683-9551